Evaluation

Leader, Evaluation

Anne Thomson »

As the emphasis on managing for results increases, the demand for independent, rigorous and evidence-based evaluations is rising. The context is changing as donors respond to the Paris Declaration principles of country ownership and harmonisation. More evaluations are being carried out jointly and there is greater involvement of recipient countries in the evaluation process.  The DAC Evaluation network brings together evaluation specialists from OECD countries and multilateral organisations to share experience and strengthen evaluation systems, including in developing countries, in particular by developing guidelines and setting standards. At the same time, donors have to account to their own taxpayers, and in some cases Parliaments, as to the effectiveness of their development assistance in contributing to poverty reduction. Methodologies are continuing to evolve to address issues of attribution and contribution, and measuring impact.

OPM is in the forefront of these trends, having just completed an evaluation of the Poverty Eradication Action Plan (PEAP) in Uganda for the Office of the Prime Minister, and also undertaken in 2005 an evaluation of Uganda’s Plan for Modernisation of Agriculture managed jointly by government and donors. OPM consultants have also undertaken a study for the Advisory Board of Irish Aid on measuring impact of aid, from bilateral and multilateral donors, and also NGOs.

OPM has considerable experience in carrying out evaluations and programme reviews for bilateral and multilateral agencies. This includes a recent evaluation of Norwegian development cooperation with Zambia, which examines power relations at the national level (including donor agencies) as a possible explanatory factor for the apparent ineffectiveness of aid to the country.  OPM has also undertaken evaluations for DFID of their country programmes in Brazil, Cambodia and Romania, for Swiss Development Cooperation of their programmes in Serbia and Montenegro and for Irish Aid of its country programme in Zambia. Recently OPM has carried out evaluations for EBRD of its Early Transition Fund and a thematic evaluation for UNICEF of its contribution to child care system reform in Central Asia.

Project Examples

Evaluation of Uganda's Poverty Eradication Action Plan (PEAP)
Client: Government of Uganda
Funder: World Bank

Evaluation of Zambia Country Programmes
Client: NORAD
Funder: NORAD

Pakistan Country Programme Evaluation
Client: DFID - Pakistan
Funder: DFID - Pakistan

ETC Fund Evaluation
Client: EBRD
Funder: EBRD

Evaluation of Plan for Modernisation of Agriculture, Uganda
Client: Government of Uganda
Funder: Danida

DFID Development Effectiveness Report
Client: DFID
Funder: DFID

Review of DFID Support to IFAD
Client: DFID
Funder: DFID

Evaluation of DFID Country Programmes
Client: DFID
Funder: DFID

Evaluation of Swiss aid to Serbia & Montenegro
Client: SDC/seco
Funder: SDC/seco

DCI Zambia Evaluation
Client: Development Cooperation Ireland
Funder: Development Cooperation Ireland

Lower Income Countries Under Stress Evaluation
Client: World Bank
Funder: World Bank

Evaluation of Danish Support for Financial Services in Tanzania
Client: Danida
Funder: Danish Ministry of Foreign Affairs

Evaluation of UNDP’s Zarafshan Valley Initiative Project
Client: Governance and Social Development Resource Centre
Funder: DFID